Why Do We Keep Making Money Decisions We Know Are Hurting Us?
Understanding the story behind our financial behaviour.
Money | Relationships | Progress
Have you ever made a financial decision knowing, even as you were making it, that you would probably regret it later?
Perhaps you bought something you didn't really need.
Perhaps you spent money you had intended to save.
Perhaps you avoided opening a bank statement because you suspected what you would find.
Or maybe you promised yourself that this month would be different, that you would spend more carefully. Stick to your budget. Reduce your debts. Start saving. Finally get your finances under control.
And for a while, things went according to plan.
Then something happened.
An unexpected expense. A stressful day. A disagreement. An irresistible opportunity. A moment of excitement. A feeling you wanted to escape.
And before you knew it, you were back where you started.
I find this aspect of human financial behaviour fascinating.
Because it raises a question that conventional financial education doesn't always adequately address.
Why do intelligent, hardworking people keep repeating financial behaviours they already know are hurting them?
Surely, if knowing what to do were enough, many of our money problems would have disappeared long ago.
But they haven't.
And I have increasingly come to believe that the explanation lies somewhere deeper than our ability to understand numbers.
When Knowing Isn't Enough
Think about how much financial advice is available today.
Spend less than you earn.
Prepare a budget.
Avoid unnecessary debt.
Build an emergency fund.
Save regularly.
Invest for the future.
Much of this advice is sensible.
And for many people, it is not particularly difficult to understand.
Yet understanding a financial principle and consistently applying it are two very different things.
Someone may know perfectly well that they should avoid unnecessary borrowing, yet repeatedly turn to credit when life becomes difficult.
Another person may understand the importance of saving but find themselves spending whenever they receive money.
Someone else may earn an excellent income and still experience considerable financial insecurity.
And there are people who have substantial savings but struggle to spend money even on things they genuinely need.
These are very different behaviours.
But they have something in common.
They cannot always be explained by a lack of financial knowledge.
Which makes me wonder:
What if some of our financial difficulties are not simply problems of money management, but patterns of behaviour that have developed for reasons we haven't fully understood?
Money Has a History
None of us begins our financial life with a completely blank slate.
Long before we earn our first salary, open a bank account or make an investment, we begin developing ideas about money.
We observe how the adults around us handle it.
We hear conversations about what can and cannot be afforded.
We experience what happens when money is scarce.
We notice how people behave when they have plenty.
We may witness arguments about spending, debt or financial responsibilities.
And sometimes we absorb lessons that nobody consciously intended to teach us.
Perhaps money was always a source of anxiety in the household where we grew up.
Perhaps asking for something meant being reminded of how difficult life was.
Perhaps spending was associated with celebration, love or belonging.
Or perhaps we learned that financial security depended on holding tightly to every penny.
These experiences do not determine our future behaviour.
But they can influence the beliefs, expectations and emotional responses we carry into adult life.
And sometimes those influences remain active long after the original circumstances have changed.
Someone who experienced financial insecurity in childhood may continue to fear running out of money even when their circumstances have improved.
Someone who learned to associate spending with affection may find themselves using purchases to express love or seek connection.
Another person may avoid dealing with financial information because money has become associated with shame, conflict or overwhelming responsibility.
Of course, not every financial habit has a deep emotional explanation.
Sometimes the issue is simply insufficient income, unexpected expenses, limited access to resources or a practical skill that has not yet been developed.
But I think we overlook something important when we assume that every money problem can be solved by giving someone better financial instructions.
Money decisions do not happen outside the experiences of the person making them.
The Person Behind the Numbers
My professional journey has given me the opportunity to look at human circumstances through different lenses.
As a Chartered Accountant, I have learned to examine financial information, identify problems, assess risks and understand the consequences of financial decisions.
As a qualified Social Worker, I have also learned to pay attention to the wider circumstances in which people live.
Their experiences.
Their relationships.
Their environments.
The pressures they face.
The strategies they have developed to cope with difficult situations.
These perspectives have led me to reflect on something.
When we look at a person's financial difficulties, what exactly are we seeing?
A bank statement might reveal repeated overdraft charges.
A credit report might show growing debts.
A budget might reveal spending that exceeds income.
These are important facts.
But they don't necessarily tell us the whole story.
They show us what is happening financially.
They may tell us very little about why it keeps happening.
For example, someone who repeatedly spends money impulsively may be struggling with emotional pressures that make spending feel temporarily comforting.
Someone who avoids opening financial letters may have come to associate those letters with anxiety or a sense of helplessness.
A person who continually supports others financially may be navigating complex expectations, family responsibilities or difficulties setting boundaries.
In each case, the visible financial behaviour may be only one part of a much larger picture.
And if we respond exclusively to the numbers, we risk overlooking the circumstances that help explain the behaviour.
The numbers can tell us where the money went. They cannot always tell us what was happening in the person's life when it went there.
I find that distinction increasingly important.
Sometimes Our Financial Habits Once Served a Purpose
There is another possibility I have been considering.
What if some financial behaviours that now create difficulties originally developed as ways of coping with earlier circumstances?
Think about someone who grew up experiencing repeated financial shortages.
Being extremely cautious with money may have helped them feel secure.
Or someone who found that buying things provided a temporary escape from difficult emotions.
Spending may have become a familiar way of managing discomfort.
Or someone who learned that keeping financial problems hidden helped them avoid conflict.
Secrecy or avoidance may once have seemed safer than asking for help.
Over time, behaviours like these can become familiar responses.
The difficulty is that a response which made sense in one set of circumstances may become unhelpful in another.
And that raises an interesting question.
Could some of the financial habits we are trying so hard to eliminate be behaviours we first need to understand?
This doesn't mean every harmful financial decision should be excused.
Nor does it mean understanding a behaviour automatically changes it.
But understanding can give us a better starting point.
Instead of simply asking, "Why can't I stop doing this?", we might begin asking:
"What tends to happen before I do this?"
"What am I feeling at that moment?"
"What does this behaviour appear to do for me?"
"What circumstances make it more likely?"
And perhaps:
"What could help me respond differently next time?"
These questions can reveal patterns that another spreadsheet may never uncover.
Relationships Are Part of Our Financial Story
There is another dimension that deserves attention.
Our relationships.
Money is often discussed as though it were an entirely individual matter.
What I earn.
What I spend.
What I save.
What I owe.
But much of our financial behaviour takes place within relationships.
We make decisions with spouses and partners.
We respond to the expectations of family members.
We compare our circumstances with those of friends and colleagues.
We support people we care about.
We sometimes spend money to belong, impress, celebrate, comfort or avoid disappointing others.
And how we communicate about money can influence the quality of our relationships.
Financial pressure can contribute to conflict.
Conflict can influence financial decisions.
A desire for acceptance can affect spending.
A sense of obligation can affect saving.
And the need to protect or provide for others can shape the risks we are willing to take.
This doesn't mean relationships are responsible for all our financial difficulties.
But it does mean that money cannot always be understood independently of the human connections surrounding it.
I also find myself considering the relationship we have with ourselves.
How do we respond when we make a financial mistake?
Do we become curious about what happened?
Or do we immediately criticise ourselves?
Do we see a setback as something to understand and address?
Or as further evidence that we are somehow incapable of managing money?
I wonder how much progress becomes possible when we replace unproductive self-condemnation with a willingness to understand our behaviour and take responsibility for changing it.
Because understanding ourselves is not the opposite of accountability. It can be one of the foundations of it.
Why Another Budget May Not Be the Answer
Imagine someone who has repeatedly tried to manage their finances.
They have prepared budgets.
Downloaded apps.
Set savings targets.
Made debt repayment plans.
And perhaps even attended financial education workshops.
Yet the same difficulties keep returning.
What would another budget accomplish?
It might help.
But perhaps the more important question is why the previous budgets did not last.
Was the plan unrealistic given their income and essential expenses?
Did it overlook irregular financial commitments?
Were there recurring situations that triggered unplanned spending?
Did relationships or household expectations interfere with the plan?
Was the person relying entirely on willpower without changing the environment in which their decisions were made?
Were there strengths and resources they had not recognised or used?
These are different questions from simply asking how much money comes in and how much goes out.
And they may lead to different solutions.
Someone struggling with emotional spending may benefit from understanding the situations that trigger it and developing alternative responses.
Someone experiencing financial avoidance may need a manageable way to engage with their finances without becoming overwhelmed.
Someone whose household spending is affected by conflicting expectations may benefit from clearer communication and shared agreements.
Someone with insufficient income may need practical financial support, access to appropriate services or opportunities to improve their earning capacity.
The most useful response depends on understanding what is actually happening.
A financial plan becomes more meaningful when it is designed for the person who must live with it.
From Financial Diagnosis to Financial Formulation
This thinking has influenced how I approach financial wellbeing.
I have become increasingly interested in moving beyond identifying financial symptoms towards understanding the circumstances and patterns that may be contributing to them.
Not simply:
How much debt do you have?
But:
How did the debt develop, and what is keeping it in place?
Not simply:
Why aren't you saving?
But:
What happens in your life that makes saving difficult to sustain?
Not simply:
What is your financial goal?
But:
What experiences, pressures, beliefs, relationships and resources may influence your ability to achieve it?
These questions form part of the thinking behind a framework I have developed called Financial Formulation™.
Its purpose is to help us understand financial difficulties in a more complete and compassionate way, while still moving towards practical action.
The approach considers six interconnected areas.
The person's current financial circumstances.
The earlier experiences and beliefs that may have shaped their relationship with money.
The events or situations that may have triggered financial difficulties.
The patterns, pressures and circumstances that may be keeping those difficulties going.
The strengths, relationships and resources that can support change.
And the practical steps, safeguards and support needed to make improvement more sustainable.
Together, these form the 6P Framework.
The intention is not to turn every financial difficulty into a psychological problem.
It is to recognise that financial behaviour can have several interacting explanations, and that effective solutions should reflect those realities.
Sometimes the answer is a better budget.
Sometimes it is additional income.
Sometimes it is a different financial system.
Sometimes it involves communication, boundaries, emotional awareness or professional support.
And sometimes it requires several of these working together.
Understanding the Story Does Not Mean Remaining in It
There is one distinction I think is especially important.
Understanding why we behave in a particular way does not mean we must continue behaving that way.
Our upbringing may influence us.
Our experiences may shape us.
Our circumstances may constrain us.
But none of these necessarily means our financial future must repeat our financial past.
Understanding a pattern can help us identify where change may be possible.
It may reveal a situation we need to prepare for.
A belief we need to reconsider.
A boundary we need to establish.
A skill we need to develop.
A relationship in which expectations need to be discussed.
Or a practical safeguard that could make a different decision easier when familiar pressures arise.
And perhaps this is where meaningful financial progress begins.
Not with pretending the past never happened.
Not with blaming ourselves for everything that has gone wrong.
But with becoming more conscious of the influences shaping our decisions and developing practical ways to respond differently.
We cannot always change the experiences that shaped our financial behaviour. But we may be able to change how we understand and respond to those patterns today.
The Question I Am Leaving With You
As I reflect on this subject, I find myself returning to the difference between knowing and understanding.
I may know that I spend too much.
But do I understand when, why and under what circumstances that spending tends to happen?
I may know that I should save more.
But do I understand what repeatedly prevents me from doing so?
I may know that my financial circumstances need to change.
But have I considered the beliefs, habits, relationships and pressures that might be influencing my choices?
And have I recognised the strengths and resources already available to help me move forward?
These questions are not intended to make money management unnecessarily complicated.
They are intended to help us look at our financial lives more completely.
Because perhaps the reason some financial plans fail is not always that we lack discipline or knowledge.
Perhaps sometimes we have been trying to change behaviours without adequately understanding the experiences and circumstances that sustain them.
And that leaves me with a thought I believe is worth considering:
What if the next significant improvement in your financial life begins not with another instruction about money, but with a better understanding of yourself?
Perhaps there is a financial pattern in your life that has persisted despite your best efforts to change it.
Before preparing another plan, it may be worth becoming curious about the story behind that pattern.
Because when we begin to understand what is happening, why it may be happening and what continues to influence it, we may discover possibilities for change that were not previously obvious.
And that is where understanding can begin to illuminate the way forward.
A Book Born from This Thinking
These reflections led me to write Financial Formulation™ — The 6P Framework to Understand Your Money Story, Break the Patterns Keeping You Stuck, and Build Lasting Financial Security, published in August 2026.
The book brings together my experience in accounting, social work and financial coaching to explore why financial knowledge does not always translate into lasting behavioural change.
It offers a practical way to examine your financial circumstances, understand recurring patterns, recognise the strengths and resources available to you, and develop realistic plans for meaningful improvement.
If you recognise some of the experiences explored in this article, the book may offer a useful starting point for examining your own financial story.
Explore Financial Formulation™ on Amazon
Because sometimes, before we can change what we do with money, we need to understand what money has come to mean in our lives.
Sterling Libs — The Money Sergeant®
Money | Relationships | Progress
Onward with Boldness

No comments:
Post a Comment
Your perspective matters. What resonated with you, challenged your thinking or gave you a different way of seeing things?
Share your reflections, experiences or questions below. Let's learn from one another with curiosity, kindness and respect.
Please challenge ideas, not people. Keep contributions constructive, relevant and respectful.
Sterling Libs | The Money Sergeant®